15 Celebrity Crushes Everyone Had in the 1990s: Did You?

4. Thandie Newton

Thandiwe / Thandie Newton’s elegance and grace set her apart as a ’90s crush. She gained recognition for her role in “Interview with the Vampire” (1994), where she played Yvette. Her striking beauty and poise captured the attention of many viewers.

Newton’s talent shone in films like “The Truth About Charlie” (2002) and “Beloved” (1998). Her ability to portray complex characters with depth and authenticity made her a respected actress, and her beauty made her a lasting celebrity crush of the decade.

These four actresses represent the slightly more obscure yet utterly captivating figures from the 1990s who left a significant impression on fans. Their unique qualities and memorable performances continue to resonate with audiences to this day.

5. Sarah Michelle Gellar

Sarah Michelle Gellar became an iconic figure in the 1990s with her role as Buffy Summers in the TV series “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” (1997-2003). This cult classic show redefined the role of women in television, presenting a strong, witty, and empowered female lead who fought supernatural evil. Gellar’s portrayal of Buffy made her a feminist icon and a crush for fans of the show. Her ability to balance humor, drama, and action endeared her to a broad audience.

Beyond Buffy, Gellar’s talent was evident in her film roles as well. She starred in “Cruel Intentions” (1999) and “I Know What You Did Last Summer” (1997), further solidifying her status as a ’90s heartthrob. Her on-screen presence and charisma made her a beloved figure of the decade & one of our top celebrity crushes.

6. Winona Ryder

Winona Ryder was an indie darling of the 1990s, known for her captivating performances in films that ranged from darkly comedic to emotionally intense. Her breakthrough role in “Beetlejuice” (1988) showcased her unique blend of beauty and quirkiness. Ryder’s portrayal of the goth teen Lydia Deetz endeared her to those who appreciated her unconventional charm.

Ryder’s career continued to flourish with roles in films like “Reality Bites” (1994), where she played a Generation X slacker navigating life’s complexities. She also starred in “Heathers” (1988), a dark comedy about high school cliques and murder. Her magnetic presence and ability to tackle complex characters made her a standout actress of the era.